Pussies - can it be TOO tight?

I'm sure that fellow bros here have access to more than one pussy.
if not, I'm pretty sure they have at least tasted/tested more than one.
my question to fellow bros, as the title said, can a pussy be too tight for you?
to clear things up, I'm not referring to those pussies that you have trouble penetrating into(be it she was born with defect, or you have an extremely large size penis). what I'm referring to is one where you two can fuck normally.


here's what happened few days ago.
was meeting my girl for some fun time. Decided to spice things up, i started giving her options, instead of doing what i usually do in bed.
like when I'm enjoying her nipples, i start asking her:
do you like this (then lick her tits and nipples from bottom to top with my tongue), or this (plant my lips on her nipples and sucks and twirl my tongue around her nipples).

this definitely turn her on a lot, being able to choose what she prefer more, and soon we are fucking like rabbits, her moans echoes in the room. and i didn't last long either, hearing her loud sexy moans, and cummed inside of her in doggy style(her favorite position).

now here's the thing, I'm guessing as she orgasm, she tightens her pussy, so tightly that it blocked me from depositing my cum inside her pussy. I can definitely feel my cum rushing down my shaft, but not cumming out from it. after my cock soften a lil bit, i pull out while pressing on to it (didn't want to mess up the bedsheet) and went to toilet. and indeed my cum is still inside my shaft, coz it blasted out as soon as i release the pressure. was a lil bit disappointed, coz i love CIP into her.